OUA Rugby All-Stars
2018
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Taylor Knezevich, Brock | Julia Schell, Guelph |
| Meagan Hart, Brock | Lexi Smith, Western |
| Lauren Van Dyke, Toronto | Brodie Schmidt, Guelph |
| Heather Bews, Waterloo | Veronica Harrigan, Western |
| Kaylah Moehling, Brock | Britni French, McMaster |
| Kashish Arya, Toronto | Madison Brattan, Guelph |
| Taylor Hurd, Brock | Emmanuela Jada, Guelph |
| Hayley Desjardins, Laurier | Rachel Hickson, Queen's |
| Katelyn Heyens, Brock | Nadia Popov, Queen's |
| Amarije Barnes, Brock | Sophie de Goede, Queen's |
| Maddy Howells, Trent | Sara Svoboda, McMaster |
| Lori Musselman, Laurier | Alexandra Everett, Guelph |
| Ben Skinner, Waterloo | Natasha Naismith, York |
| Francesca Griffin, Toronto | Emilie Nicholl, Guelph |
| Breanna Jeremiah, Brock | Monique Sluys, McMaster |
2017
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Meagan Hart, Brock | Julia Schell, Guelph* |
| Amarije Barnes, Brock | Kylie Shaughnessy, Guelph |
| Kaylah Moehling, Brock | Madison Brattan, Guelph |
| Katelyn Heyens, Brock | Emilie Nicholl, Guelph |
| Jenna Rainville, Brock | Chloe Runge, Guelph |
| Jordan Semark, Trent | Sara Svoboda, McMaster* |
| Kristy Metzger, Trent | Britt French, McMaster* |
| Maddy Howells, Trent | Selena Seguin, McMaster |
| Anna Pypker, Trent | Cassidy Calvert, McMaster |
| Lori Musselman, Laurier | McKinley Hunt, Queen's |
| Shannon Bellamy, Laurier | Kara Gani, Queen's |
| Michaela Strong, Laurier | Sophie de Goede, Queen's |
| Robyn Feraday, Toronto | Tobi Owotomo, York |
| Khadijat Dhako, Toronto | Petra Woods, York* |
| Kiera Mathers, Waterloo | Nicole Case, Western* |
2016
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Britni French, McMaster | Julia Schell, Guelph* |
| Sara Svoboda, McMaster* | Alexandra King, Guelph |
| Colleen Irowa, McMaster* | Kylie Shaughnessy, Guelph |
| Katie Svoboda, McMaster* | Devon Stober, Guelph |
| Abigail Moody, McMaster | Alyssa McDonald, Guelph |
| Lauren Murray, Queen's | Veronica Harrigan, Western |
| McKinley Hunt, Queen's* | Lexi Smith, Western |
| Miranda Seifert, Queen's | Paige Farries, Western* |
| Nadia Popov, Queen's* | Nicole Case, Western* |
| Dorrian Khouri, York | Meagan Hart, Brock |
| Tobi Owotomo, York* | Amarije Barnes, Brock |
| Petra Woods, York* | Vanessa Cifuentes, Brock |
| Jordyn Orlando, Toronto | Danielle Duncan, Waterloo |
| Lauren Van Dyke, Toronto | Jessie Brush, Waterloo |
| Jessica Hercus, Trent | Chloe Graves, Laurier |
2015
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Cindy Nelles, McMaster* | Dria Keane, Guelph* |
| Emily Ricketts, McMaster | Bronwyn McCrone, Guelph |
| Colleen Irowa, McMaster | Brittany Kassil, Guelph* |
| Katie Svoboda, McMaster* | Devon Stober, Guelph |
| Abigail Moody, McMaster | Alexandra King, Guelph* |
| Lauren McEwen, Queen's | Andrea Bowra, Western |
| Emma Chown, Queen's | Rebecca Matheson, Western |
| Gillian Pegg, Queen's* | Paige Farries, Western |
| Pippi McKay, Queen's | Nicole Case, Western* |
| Cheyenne Legerton, York | Jennifer Gilmour, Laurier |
| Marty Alaimo, York | Chloe Graves, Laurier |
| Bobbi-Jo Cronk, York | Kelly Martin, Laurier |
| Karlie Robinson, Trent | Katelyn Heyens, Brock |
| Carlie Maloney, Trent | Chelsea Brathwaite, Brock |
| Olivia Roberge, Toronto | Elizabete Alves, Waterloo |
2014
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Cindy Nelles, McMaster* | Brittany Priddle, Guelph* |
| Emily Ricketts, McMaster | Shannon Spurrell, Guelph |
| Sara Svoboda, McMaster | Brittany Kassil, Guelph |
| Abigail Moody, McMaster | Devon Stober, Guelph |
| Heidi Henderson, McMaster | Rita Charest-Pekeski, Guelph |
| Lauren McEwen, Queen's* | Megan Colwell, Waterloo |
| Miranda Seifert, Queen's | Tina Tuck, Waterloo |
| Gillian Pegg, Queen's* | Rachel Brown, Waterloo |
| Melody Clarke, Queen's | Erika Schroeder, Waterloo |
| Dorrian Khouri, York* | Lori Josephson, Western* |
| Fedelia Omoghan, York | Mackenzie Fane, Western |
| Zoe Smith, York | Ashley Snider, Western |
| Karlie Robinson, Trent | Jennifer Gilmour, Laurier |
| Jessica Hercus, Trent | Kelly Martin, Laurier |
| Bianca Marchione, Toronto | Katie Faust, Brock |
2013
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Claragh Pegg, Queen's* | Brittany Kassil, Guelph |
| Loren Baldwin, Queen's | Caitlin McNally, Guelph* |
| Devon Stride, Queen's | Shannon Spurrell, Guelph |
| Lauren McEwen, Queen's* | Brittany Priddle, Guelph |
| Karley Heyman, Queen's | Devon Keys, Guelph |
| Cindy Nelles, McMaster* | Lori Josephson, Western* |
| Stephanie Black, McMaster | Breanne Nicholas, Western |
| Emily Ricketts, McMaster | Danielle Spice, Western |
| Sarah Farquharson, McMaster | Brandie Kirk, Western |
| Fedelia Omoghan, York | Renee Woodhouse, Waterloo |
| Aisan Fazeli, York | Kourtney King, Waterloo |
| Zoe Smith, York | Bryanna Bryans, Waterloo |
| Alannah Bailey, Trent | Jennifer Gilmour, Laurier |
| Sarah Guttin, Trent | Chloe Graves, Laurier |
| Olivia Roberge, Toronto | Liz Hunnick, Brock |
2012
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Taylor White, Queen's* | Brittany Benn, Guelph* |
| Bronwyn Corrigan, Queen's | Caitlin Beaton, Guelph* |
| Claragh Pegg, Queen's | Morganne Linthwaite, Guelph |
| Susan Heald, Queen's | MacKenzie Higgs, Guelph |
| Nadia Popov, Queen's | Caitlin McNally, Guelph* |
| Sarah Berry, McMaster | Briana Cunningham, Waterloo* |
| Marisa Ashley, McMaster | Erinne Lee Vargas, Waterloo |
| Maggie Cogger-Orr, McMaster | Renee Woodhouse, Waterloo |
| Stephanie Black, McMaster | Rachel Brown, Waterloo |
| Fedelia Omoghan, York | Lori Josephson, Western |
| Amber Barrett, York | Mackenzie Fane, Western |
| Mel Cunningham, York | Meaghann Buitinga, Western |
| Britt Douglas, Trent | Elizabeth Monkman, Brock |
| Kaitlyn Newton, Trent | Mariko Reilly, Brock |
| Karla Telidetzki, Toronto* | Emily Seunarine, Laurier |
2011
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Natasha Turner, McMaster* | Jacey Murphy, Guelph* |
| Cindy Nelles, McMaster | Brittany Benn, Guelph |
| Varsha Tripathi, McMaster | Caitlin Beaton, Guelph |
| Kim Ngai, McMaster | Caitlin McNally, Guelph |
| Maggie Cogger-Orr, McMaster | Stephanie Tibelius, Guelph |
| Susan Heald, Queen's | Kaley Maksymyk, Waterloo |
| Taylor White, Queen's | Shannon Holder, Waterloo |
| Claragh Pegg, Queen's | Briana Cunningham, Waterloo |
| Ashley Burton, Trent | Savannah Gentile, Waterloo |
| Kaitlin Newton, Trent | Hannah Wilson, Brock |
| Lauren Wizowski, Trent | Misha Maric, Brock |
| Jolene John, York | Mariko Reilly, Brock |
| Lee-Anne Corrigan, Toronto | Arielle Dubissette, Western* |
| Karla Telidetzki, Toronto* | Allie Walker, Western |
| Sarah Campbell, York | Trish Shurrie, Laurier |
2010
| Russell Division | Shiels Division |
| Ash Ward, Queen's* | Jacey Murphy, Guelph* |
| Jocelyn Poirier, Queen's | Brittany Benn, Guelph* |
| Susan Heald, Queen's | Caitlin Beaton, Guelph |
| Andrea Wadsworth, Queen's | Jane Kirby, Guelph |
| Karlye Wong, Queen's | Stephanie deVries, Guelph |
| Natasha Turner, McMaster* | Caitlin Martin, Waterloo |
| Allison Morris, McMaster | Sam Eyles, Waterloo |
| Varsha Tripathi, McMaster | Briana Cunningham, Waterloo |
| Claire Lockhart, McMaster | Renee Woodhouse, Waterloo |
| Tiera Thomas-Reynolds, York | Holly Monkman, Brock |
| Melissa Cunningham, York | Misha Maric, Brock |
| Jolene John, York | Rachael McMaster, Western |
| Louise Chen, Toronto | Elizabeth Wilson, Western |
| Lee-Anne Corrigan, Toronto | Kayley Powers, Laurier |
| Whitney Black, Trent |